What Is the Average Settlement for a Minor Car Accident?

In minor car accidents, the average settlement amount ranges from $10,000 – $15,000. However, this amount is not final because each car accident and personal injury case is unique. The compensation you receive depends on different factors like property damage, the severity of injuries, medical expenses, lost income, or pain and suffering.

Therefore, if you’re a victim of a car crash and looking for legal options to recover your losses, consult Uptown Injury Law, PLLC car accident lawyers. Our attorneys understand the challenges you may face in resolving your case. Our team is ready to help you get the maximum settlement you deserve.

average car accident settlement - car accident lawyer new york

How Do Minor Car Accident Settlements Work?

Settling a minor car accident can seem complex, but here’s a simplified way of how minor car accident settlement works.

First of all, following your car accident, you must ensure your safety by reaching a safe place and calling the local police. If the accident is the fault of another driver, then you are likely eligible to file an insurance claim and get the compensation. However, to prove this, you’ll need to gather your documents, such as medical bills, police reports, and other important evidence. 

Furthermore, if your minor car crash resulted in lost wages or income, you must collect a salary verification statement to prove your lost income. Your car accident lawyer can collect all the necessary evidence for you.

Next, you’ll need to report the accident to your insurance company. They will investigate the incident and assess your damages. In minor accidents, your insurance company can directly negotiate with the other driver’s insurer to reach a settlement.

After that, you’ll receive an initial offer, which you can choose to accept or negotiate further. However, if you’re not satisfied with the settlement amount, you can seek legal advice or consult with an experienced car accident attorney for guidance. 

Factors Affecting Car Accident Settlements

Several key factors come into play when determining the typical car accident settlement amount, such as:

Severity of Damages and Injuries

The severity of damages you suffered as a result of the accident is a major factor in determining your car accident settlement. For instance, if you were severely injured and/or your vehicle was seriously damaged, in that case, then you will likely deserve a higher payout. You may compensation for:

  • The cost of repairs
  • Cost of replacing any parts of the vehicle
  • Your vehicle’s overall value
  • Emotional suffering 

Medical Expenses and Treatment Duration

The medical costs you pay can also determine the car accident settlement amount. Such expenses include:

  • Medical care costs
  • Ambulance fees
  • Emergency room visits
  • Doctor consultations
  • Any required diagnostic tests

Additionally, if your injuries need ongoing treatment, such as physical therapy or follow-up appointments, these expenses can also affect your personal injury settlement. Therefore, you must maintain detailed records of all your medical bills and treatment.

Property Damage and Repair Costs

If you were in a minor car accident, it caused damage to your vehicle, and you had to pay repair costs related to it. These damages or repair costs can influence your car accident settlement amount. These costs may involve:

  • Visible damages such as frame or trunk damage
  • Structural or mechanical issues

Therefore, to receive proper compensation for your property damages, you must hire a personal injury attorney who specializes in dealing with minor car accidents and can help you determine the accurate value of your claim. 

Pain and Suffering 

The emotional and mental toll of a car accident can not be overlooked. If you experience pain and suffering due to a minor car accident, then it can influence your personal injury settlement. Typically, pain and suffering damages include:

  • Emotional distress
  • Anxiety
  • Any lasting discomfort like fear or trauma

New York State Laws

State laws play a considerable part in determining your settlement amount for car accidents. For example, New York follows a no-fault insurance system. This means that, in the event of a car accident, your own insurance company is responsible for covering your medical expenses and all the other losses, regardless of who was at fault.

If you step outside the no-fault system and pursue a personal injury claim against the other driver, you’ve to prove that your injuries are severe, as established by New York law. If you remain successful in validating that you suffered from serious injuries, then you have a higher chance of receiving a huge settlement amount.

Furthermore, New York follows a comparative negligence rule, which means that if you’re at fault for the accident, it can affect your settlement. This rule simply means that you can still recover your damages, but your settlement will be reduced according to your level of fault. Also, the statute of limitations in each state can also impact the settlement amount you may receive.

Insurance Policies

Your insurance policies and the insurance coverage of the other driver can influence your car accident settlement amount. To understand this, you can look into these examples:

  • Your liability coverage is the primary factor that can influence your settlement. If you are at fault for the accident, your liability coverage will cover all the damages to the other party. The higher your liability limits, the more financial protection you have.
  • If you have collision coverage, it can impact your settlement amount, especially when you’re at fault. This coverage can help cover the repair cost of your own vehicle, reducing your out-of-pocket expenses.
  • PIP coverage can be crucial in a minor accident, as it helps cover your medical expenses, regardless of fault. It can also compensate for lost wages, which might affect your overall settlement.

How to Calculate Your Settlement Amount After a Car Accident?

Calculating car accident settlements is a subjective aspect of a personal injury lawsuit, and it can also vary due to your state’s jurisdiction and your specific case.

However, you can use these standard methods to calculate the value of your average settlement in a minor car accident. These methods are:

Multiplier Method

This method involves multiplying your medical bills and lost wages by a specific multiplier. The multiplier number ranges between 1 to 5. The seriousness of the injury and how much it affects your life will decide how much compensation you deserve.

For instance, if the severity of your injury is at multiplier 3 and your medical bills or lost wages are up to $50,000, then your settlement amount will be $150,000 ($50,000 x 3).

Per Diem Method

In this approach, a daily rate is assigned to your damages. This daily rate is multiplied by the days you experience physical and emotional suffering due to the injury. This method is more straightforward for cases with temporary or minor injuries with a precise recovery period.

For example, if you stayed in the hospital for 100 days after your car accident and your daily rate is $600, then the amount of your suffering settlement will be $60,000 ($600 x 100).

Typical Settlement Amounts in Minor Car Accidents

new york car accident lawyer

The settlement amounts in minor car crashes can vary based on the severity of injury, lost income, emotional suffering, medical costs, and property damage. However, here are some car accident settlement examples for your reference:

  • The average car accident settlement is around $25,446; for the truck accident, is $73,109; and for motorcycle accidents, the average settlement is $79,344.
  • According to Martindale-Nolo, the average car accident compensation is $29,700 for physical injuries. However, the settlement amount for minor injuries is between $5,000 to $8,200.
  • According to the Insurance Information Institute, from 2012-2021, auto liability coverage for bodily injury ranges from $14,690 to $22,734.
  • The average settlement amount for property damage is between $3,073 to $5,314.
  • Depending on the state, other studies show that the minimum settlement for property damage in auto accidents ranges from $5,000 to $25,000.
  • Bodily injury compensation per person is between $15,000 to $50,000, and per accident compensation is from $30,000 to $100,000.

How to Maximize the Settlement Amount in a Car Accident Lawsuit?

To get a fair settlement from your car accident, you need to follow a strategic approach that builds a strong case from all aspects. First and foremost, seek immediate medical treatment if you’re injured, as your well-being should be your top concern. Once that’s taken care of, you must collect strong evidence at the accident scene. This evidence can include:

  • Pictures of damages to the vehicles involved
  • Road conditions
  • Running traffic signs or signals
  • Eyewitness statements and their contact information

Similarly, make sure to get an official police report for your accident because this can provide crucial documentation of the incident and increase the chances of getting more compensation. Also, you should document your injuries and maintain a detailed record of your medical treatment and expenses. However, if you fail to record your injuries, you can’t expect a bigger payout in such incidents.

Lastly, to maximize your car accident settlement, you’ll need to negotiate with the insurance adjusters and maintain patience. Settling too quickly can lead to lower compensation. 

Being a New York car accident law firm, we can’t stress enough to consult a personal injury lawyer before accepting any settlement from the insurance company. 

How Long It Takes to Get Settlement for Minor Crashes?

If you’re in a minor car accident, you might wonder how long it takes to receive compensation for the damages and injuries you’ve sustained. 

In minor cases where liability is clear and both parties cooperate, you may see a settlement within a few weeks to a few months. However, the time it takes to reach a resolution can also depend on factors like the negotiation with the other party’s insurance and any potential disputes.

Additionally, it’s important to understand that quick settlements may not always be in your best interest, as you should cover all your damages. If negotiations with the insurance company prove challenging or the other party is uncooperative, the settlement process may take longer. 

Therefore, you should consult a personal injury attorney if the offer doesn’t compensate you fairly for your losses. While the timing of your settlement can vary, your patience and diligence in handling the process can help you secure a fair settlement payout.

What Are the Biggest Car Accident Settlement Amounts Ever Won in New York?

If you’re curious about the largest car accident settlement amounts ever secured in NYC, you’ll be intrigued to look into these examples, such as:

  1. At Uptown Injury Law, our best car crash lawyer in New York, Kyle Newman, secured $1,800,000 for a hit in a rear/commercial policy car accident. 
  2. In 2021, author and former New York Times columnist Devan Sipher secured $85 million for injuries in a pedestrian-bus accident.
  3. Former student Morgan Wang at Cornell University got the settlement amount of $70 million after suffering from spinal cord injuries in a head-on collision. 
  4. A passenger struck by a tractor-trailer secured $2,000,000 in settlement. 
  5. The driver struck by an ambulette received a settlement amount of $930,000 after a car accident in New York County. 
  6. The family of five injured in a NY city car crash got compensation of $930,000. 

How a Lawyer Can Help You Maximize Your Car Accident Claim?

Here are some benefits of seeking assistance from a car accident lawyer:

Maximize the Value of Your Claim

Personal injury attorneys bring valuable experience to your car accident case. They have negotiation skills, handle legal paperwork, and advocate for your rights effectively. A car accident lawyer understands how to assess the actual value of your case and ensure that you don’t settle for less than you deserve.

Identify Situations Where Legal Help Is Advisable

Certain situations call for legal assistance. If you are facing rejections from insurance companies and dealing with long-term injuries. In such cases, seeking legal help becomes important. A car accident attorney can safeguard your rights and ensure you are not exploited during settlement discussions.

Seek Compensation for Minor Crash━Consult Uptown Injury!

Car accidents happen when we least expect them, and even a minor car collision can leave you facing unexpected medical bills, vehicle repairs, and emotional stress. At Uptown Injury Law Firm, our team of experienced car accident lawyers specialize in turning your setback into a comeback. With our personalized approach, we customize our strategies to fit your unique circumstances, ensuring the best possible outcome for your case.

We are not only the best car accident lawyers in New York City, but we also provide services in the 

With a track record of securing million-dollar compensation, we have numerous settlements and verdicts from our past clients. Our car accident lawyers are currently serving car accident victims in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, and Staten Island.

Contact us or call our office number toll-free at 917-540-8728 to schedule your FREE consultation.


What Is the Average Payout for a Minor Car Accident?

The payout for a minor car accident may be between $10,000 – $20,000. However, this amount can change based on factors such as the extent of damage to your vehicle, any injuries sustained, and the insurance policies involved. However, there is no fixed “average” payout for minor accidents, as each case is unique.

How Much Is Your Car Accident Worth?

The worth of your car accident depends on the specific details of your case. It typically includes compensation for property damage, medical bills, lost income, and pain and suffering. 

To determine the worth of your accident, it’s advisable to consult with a car accident lawyer who can evaluate your case and provide you with an estimate based on their expertise.

How Much Should You Settle For After a Car Accident?

The appropriate settlement amount after a car accident is a complex matter and can vary widely. To ensure a fair settlement, consider consulting with a personal injury lawyer who can help you deal with the insurance companies involved and advocate for your best interests.

What Factors Influence Car Accident Settlement Amount?

The typical car accident settlement amount depends on factors like the extent of injuries, property damage, medical expenses, and insurance coverage.

Can I Seek a Car Accident Injury Settlement?

Yes, you can seek accident settlement if you suffer any injuries caused by someone else’s negligence. In such cases, you have the legal right to pursue a settlement to cover your medical costs, pain and suffering, or lost wages.

How Is Property Damage Covered in an Auto Accident Settlement? 

Property damage is covered through the at-fault party’s liability insurance. When you are not responsible for the accident, the at-fault driver’s insurance can compensate you for repairing or replacing your damaged vehicle.

Is It Necessary to Hire an Attorney for Personal Injury Claims?

Yes, hiring a lawyer can be beneficial for your personal injury claim. A personal injury lawyer can help you navigate legal complexities and secure fair auto accident settlements.

What Is the Role of Insurance Companies in Settling Minor Car Accident Claims?

An insurance company helps in examining and managing the financial aspects of your auto accident. Furthermore, these insurers investigate your car accident case, review the provided evidence, and determine liability based on the circumstances and applicable laws.

How Can I Maximize My Bodily Injury Liability Coverage After a Car Accident? 

You can increase your liability coverage by gathering evidence, documenting serious injuries and lost income, and communicating with the insurance company. Additionally, you can consult a car accident lawyer to determine your fair liability coverage.


Kyle Newman Founder and Senior Trial Lawyer at Uptown Injury Law New York's Best Personal Injury Medical Malpractice and Accident Law firm New York's Top Trial Lawyers
Kyle Newman Founder and Senior Trial Lawyer at Uptown Injury Law New York's Best Personal Injury Medical Malpractice and Accident Law firm New York's Top Trial Lawyers

This content is trustworthy because it has been thoroughly researched, fact-checked and reviewed by experts in the field. The information provided is accurate and reliable, and sources have been cited to ensure transparency and credibility. The authors or publishers of this content have a reputation for producing high-quality, unbiased material. Additionally, any potential conflicts of interest or biases have been disclosed. Overall, readers can trust that the information presented in this content is trustworthy and credible.